gaeta’s Italian Bakery

Tomato Pies, Pizza & Strombolis

Cash & Take Out Only
Check Facebook and Instagram for Daily Specials

Wholesale Locations

Menu (PDF)

– MENU –

Original Square Tomato Pies

Large: Full Sheet (24 Slices)

Tomato Pie

$29

Cut 1/2 $30

w/ Half (1/2) Sheet Cheese

$32

w/ Full Sheet Cheese

$35

Toppings Extra

Large $6

Medium: Half Sheet (12 Slices)

Tomato Pie

$17

Cut 1/2 $18

w/ Quarter (1/4) Sheet Cheese

$19

w/ Half (1/2) Sheet Cheese

$20

Toppings Extra

Medium $3

Small: Quarter Sheet (6 Slices)

Tomato Pie

$9

w/ Three (3) Slices), Cheese

$10

w/ All Six (6) Slices, Cheese

$11

Stuffed Breads Stromboli

Pepperoni & Cheese

$16

Steak & Cheese

$16

Buffalo Chicken & Cheese

$16

Sausage & Cheese

$16

Spinach & Cheese

$16

Broccoli & Cheese

$16

Four (4) Cheeses

$16

Bacon, Egg & Cheese

$18

Steak, Egg & Cheese

$18

Pork Roll, Egg & Cheese

$18

Peppers, Egg & Cheese

$18

Oreganato (Specify Mild or Hot)

$14

White Pie (Square)

Medium: Half Sheet (12 Slices)

Plain

$17

w/ Cheese $20

w/ Spinach or Broccoli + Cheese & Tomato

$23

Traditional Cheese Pizza (Round)

18″ Extra Large

$16

1 Topping $19

16″ Large

$14

1 Topping $16

Toppings

Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Sweet Peppers, Onions, Spinach, Broccoli, Roasted Garlic, Tomatoes

Bread

Long Bread

$3

2 for $5

Sandwiches

Roast Pork Sandwich on our Fresh Bread

$13

Seasoned to Perfection and Slow Roasted w/ Pride

Add-on: Sharp Provolone, Sautéed Spinach and/or Shaved Provolone

Yelp Reviews



Kathy S.

January 23, 2024

The best tomato pie around, bar none. The price is reasonable for the amount of pie that they serve. The workers are extremely friendly.

☆☆☆☆☆

Lee C.

July 7, 2023

This is fantastic tomato pie and pizza! The gravy is amazing on both the pies and pizza with a hint of sweetness to it and the crust is done to perfection ~ crispy and thin. Gaeta’s also does a wonderful white pizza with a touch of olive oil and tomatoes that is truly superb. This is a family staple ~ and something that is ordered for every occasion. The tomato pies make excellent appetizers ~ just double cut the slices! Friendly service, incredible food and so very accommodating…Gaeta’s is exceptional.

☆☆☆☆☆

Thao T.

July 23, 2022

I drive on Castor all the time and never realized this gem was hidden across the McDonald’s. I depend of yelp to help me find good foods and the reviews do matter. I got the tomato pie with cheese and just to say it was the best around this area. You won’t be disappointed. very accommodating…Gaeta’s is exceptional.

☆☆☆☆☆